I went and saw this in theaters. I came out pleasantly suprised by it's effectiveness as a horror/thriller. I didn't expect it to be that way just looking at the cast, but it was very fun and smart too. Frank Whaley was great as the creepy innkeeper, and I agree that Luke Wilson showed us what he has to offer in what seems likely to be his best performance yet. I also agree that the ending wasn't as strong as the rest of the film. Overall, this was a good thriller to watch on the couch. I'd stick with around 7/10.